Week 4 start/sit close calls

Updated Oct 4, 2026, 1:30 AM ET · Not listed? Use the Start/Sit assistant for any 2-4 players.

QB

• Josh Allen or Tyler Shough? Josh Allen 55% (half-PPR)
• Josh Allen or Patrick Mahomes? Josh Allen 63% (half-PPR)
• Josh Allen or Lamar Jackson? Josh Allen 64% (half-PPR)
• Tyler Shough or Patrick Mahomes? Tyler Shough 58% (half-PPR)
• Tyler Shough or Lamar Jackson? Tyler Shough 58% (half-PPR)
• Tyler Shough or Bryce Young? Tyler Shough 58% (half-PPR)
• Patrick Mahomes or Lamar Jackson? Patrick Mahomes 51% (half-PPR)
• Patrick Mahomes or Bryce Young? Patrick Mahomes 52% (half-PPR)
• Patrick Mahomes or Drake Maye? Patrick Mahomes 52% (half-PPR)
• Lamar Jackson or Bryce Young? Lamar Jackson 51% (half-PPR)
• Lamar Jackson or Drake Maye? Lamar Jackson 51% (half-PPR)
• Lamar Jackson or Jared Goff? Lamar Jackson 52% (half-PPR)
• Bryce Young or Drake Maye? Bryce Young 51% (half-PPR)
• Bryce Young or Jared Goff? Bryce Young 52% (half-PPR)
• Bryce Young or Tyson Bagent? Bryce Young 52% (half-PPR)
• Drake Maye or Jared Goff? Drake Maye 50% (half-PPR)
• Drake Maye or Tyson Bagent? Drake Maye 51% (half-PPR)
• Drake Maye or Marcus Mariota? Drake Maye 51% (half-PPR)
• Jared Goff or Tyson Bagent? Jared Goff 51% (half-PPR)
• Jared Goff or Marcus Mariota? Jared Goff 50% (half-PPR)
• Jared Goff or Deshaun Watson? Jared Goff 50% (half-PPR)
• Tyson Bagent or Marcus Mariota? Tyson Bagent 51% (half-PPR)
• Tyson Bagent or Deshaun Watson? Tyson Bagent 50% (half-PPR)
• Tyson Bagent or Joe Burrow? Tyson Bagent 50% (half-PPR)
• Marcus Mariota or Deshaun Watson? Marcus Mariota 50% (half-PPR)
• Marcus Mariota or Joe Burrow? Marcus Mariota 50% (half-PPR)
• Marcus Mariota or Dak Prescott? Marcus Mariota 50% (half-PPR)
• Deshaun Watson or Joe Burrow? Deshaun Watson 50% (half-PPR)
• Deshaun Watson or Dak Prescott? Deshaun Watson 51% (half-PPR)
• Deshaun Watson or C.J. Stroud? Deshaun Watson 51% (half-PPR)
• Joe Burrow or Dak Prescott? Joe Burrow 50% (half-PPR)
• Joe Burrow or C.J. Stroud? Joe Burrow 51% (half-PPR)
• Joe Burrow or Brock Purdy? Joe Burrow 50% (half-PPR)
• Dak Prescott or C.J. Stroud? Dak Prescott 49% (half-PPR)
• Dak Prescott or Brock Purdy? Dak Prescott 50% (half-PPR)
• Dak Prescott or Bo Nix? Dak Prescott 51% (half-PPR)
• C.J. Stroud or Brock Purdy? C.J. Stroud 50% (half-PPR)
• C.J. Stroud or Bo Nix? C.J. Stroud 52% (half-PPR)
• C.J. Stroud or Jacoby Brissett? C.J. Stroud 54% (half-PPR)
• Brock Purdy or Bo Nix? Brock Purdy 52% (half-PPR)
• Brock Purdy or Jacoby Brissett? Brock Purdy 54% (half-PPR)
• Bo Nix or Jacoby Brissett? Bo Nix 52% (half-PPR)

RB

• Jahmyr Gibbs or Bijan Robinson? Jahmyr Gibbs 52% (half-PPR)
• Jahmyr Gibbs or Aaron Jones Sr.? Jahmyr Gibbs 61% (half-PPR)
• Jahmyr Gibbs or Kenneth Walker III? Jahmyr Gibbs 63% (half-PPR)
• Bijan Robinson or Aaron Jones Sr.? Bijan Robinson 59% (half-PPR)
• Bijan Robinson or Kenneth Walker III? Bijan Robinson 62% (half-PPR)
• Bijan Robinson or James Cook III? Bijan Robinson 66% (half-PPR)
• Aaron Jones Sr. or Kenneth Walker III? Aaron Jones Sr. 52% (half-PPR)
• Aaron Jones Sr. or James Cook III? Aaron Jones Sr. 57% (half-PPR)
• Aaron Jones Sr. or Derrick Henry? Aaron Jones Sr. 57% (half-PPR)
• Kenneth Walker III or James Cook III? Kenneth Walker III 55% (half-PPR)
• Kenneth Walker III or Derrick Henry? Kenneth Walker III 55% (half-PPR)
• Kenneth Walker III or Jaylen Warren? Kenneth Walker III 56% (half-PPR)
• James Cook III or Derrick Henry? James Cook III 50% (half-PPR)
• James Cook III or Jaylen Warren? James Cook III 52% (half-PPR)
• James Cook III or Jonathan Taylor? James Cook III 52% (half-PPR)
• Derrick Henry or Jaylen Warren? Derrick Henry 51% (half-PPR)
• Derrick Henry or Jonathan Taylor? Derrick Henry 52% (half-PPR)
• Derrick Henry or Christian McCaffrey? Derrick Henry 55% (half-PPR)
• Jaylen Warren or Jonathan Taylor? Jaylen Warren 51% (half-PPR)
• Jaylen Warren or Christian McCaffrey? Jaylen Warren 54% (half-PPR)
• Jaylen Warren or Kyren Williams? Jaylen Warren 56% (half-PPR)
• Jonathan Taylor or Christian McCaffrey? Jonathan Taylor 54% (half-PPR)
• Jonathan Taylor or Kyren Williams? Jonathan Taylor 55% (half-PPR)
• Jonathan Taylor or Ashton Jeanty? Jonathan Taylor 58% (half-PPR)
• Christian McCaffrey or Kyren Williams? Christian McCaffrey 51% (half-PPR)
• Christian McCaffrey or Ashton Jeanty? Christian McCaffrey 54% (half-PPR)
• Christian McCaffrey or Chuba Hubbard? Christian McCaffrey 56% (half-PPR)
• Kyren Williams or Ashton Jeanty? Kyren Williams 53% (half-PPR)
• Kyren Williams or Chuba Hubbard? Kyren Williams 55% (half-PPR)
• Kyren Williams or Chase Brown? Kyren Williams 56% (half-PPR)
• Ashton Jeanty or Chuba Hubbard? Ashton Jeanty 53% (half-PPR)
• Ashton Jeanty or Chase Brown? Ashton Jeanty 54% (half-PPR)
• Ashton Jeanty or Javonte Williams? Ashton Jeanty 55% (half-PPR)
• Chuba Hubbard or Chase Brown? Chuba Hubbard 52% (half-PPR)
• Chuba Hubbard or Javonte Williams? Chuba Hubbard 52% (half-PPR)
• Chuba Hubbard or Bucky Irving? Chuba Hubbard 52% (half-PPR)
• Chase Brown or Javonte Williams? Chase Brown 51% (half-PPR)
• Chase Brown or Bucky Irving? Chase Brown 50% (half-PPR)
• Chase Brown or D'Andre Swift? Chase Brown 52% (half-PPR)
• Javonte Williams or Bucky Irving? Javonte Williams 50% (half-PPR)
• Javonte Williams or D'Andre Swift? Javonte Williams 52% (half-PPR)
• Javonte Williams or Jeremiyah Love? Javonte Williams 53% (half-PPR)
• Bucky Irving or D'Andre Swift? Bucky Irving 52% (half-PPR)
• Bucky Irving or Jeremiyah Love? Bucky Irving 54% (half-PPR)
• Bucky Irving or Alvin Kamara? Bucky Irving 59% (half-PPR)
• D'Andre Swift or Jeremiyah Love? D'Andre Swift 53% (half-PPR)
• D'Andre Swift or Alvin Kamara? D'Andre Swift 57% (half-PPR)
• D'Andre Swift or Quinshon Judkins? D'Andre Swift 60% (half-PPR)
• Jeremiyah Love or Alvin Kamara? Jeremiyah Love 55% (half-PPR)
• Jeremiyah Love or Quinshon Judkins? Jeremiyah Love 57% (half-PPR)
• Jeremiyah Love or Braelon Allen? Jeremiyah Love 60% (half-PPR)
• Alvin Kamara or Quinshon Judkins? Alvin Kamara 53% (half-PPR)
• Alvin Kamara or Braelon Allen? Alvin Kamara 57% (half-PPR)
• Alvin Kamara or Emanuel Wilson? Alvin Kamara 57% (half-PPR)
• Quinshon Judkins or Braelon Allen? Quinshon Judkins 54% (half-PPR)
• Quinshon Judkins or Emanuel Wilson? Quinshon Judkins 54% (half-PPR)
• Quinshon Judkins or Bhayshul Tuten? Quinshon Judkins 54% (half-PPR)
• Braelon Allen or Emanuel Wilson? Braelon Allen 51% (half-PPR)
• Braelon Allen or Bhayshul Tuten? Braelon Allen 49% (half-PPR)
• Braelon Allen or Rhamondre Stevenson? Braelon Allen 51% (half-PPR)
• Emanuel Wilson or Bhayshul Tuten? Emanuel Wilson 49% (half-PPR)
• Emanuel Wilson or Rhamondre Stevenson? Emanuel Wilson 51% (half-PPR)
• Emanuel Wilson or J.K. Dobbins? Emanuel Wilson 52% (half-PPR)
• Bhayshul Tuten or Rhamondre Stevenson? Bhayshul Tuten 52% (half-PPR)
• Bhayshul Tuten or J.K. Dobbins? Bhayshul Tuten 53% (half-PPR)
• Bhayshul Tuten or Omarion Hampton? Bhayshul Tuten 53% (half-PPR)
• Rhamondre Stevenson or J.K. Dobbins? Rhamondre Stevenson 51% (half-PPR)
• Rhamondre Stevenson or Omarion Hampton? Rhamondre Stevenson 51% (half-PPR)
• J.K. Dobbins or Omarion Hampton? J.K. Dobbins 50% (half-PPR)
• J.K. Dobbins or Cam Skattebo? J.K. Dobbins 51% (half-PPR)
• Omarion Hampton or Cam Skattebo? Omarion Hampton 51% (half-PPR)
• Omarion Hampton or Austin Ekeler? Omarion Hampton 51% (half-PPR)
• Cam Skattebo or Austin Ekeler? Cam Skattebo 50% (half-PPR)
• Cam Skattebo or Saquon Barkley? Cam Skattebo 50% (half-PPR)
• Cam Skattebo or David Montgomery? Cam Skattebo 51% (half-PPR)
• Austin Ekeler or Saquon Barkley? Austin Ekeler 50% (half-PPR)
• Austin Ekeler or David Montgomery? Austin Ekeler 51% (half-PPR)
• Saquon Barkley or David Montgomery? Saquon Barkley 52% (half-PPR)

WR

• Jaxon Smith-Njigba or Chris Olave? Jaxon Smith-Njigba 57% (half-PPR)
• Jaxon Smith-Njigba or Ja'Marr Chase? Jaxon Smith-Njigba 56% (half-PPR)
• Jaxon Smith-Njigba or Amon-Ra St. Brown? Jaxon Smith-Njigba 57% (half-PPR)
• Chris Olave or Ja'Marr Chase? Chris Olave 50% (half-PPR)
• Chris Olave or Amon-Ra St. Brown? Chris Olave 51% (half-PPR)
• Chris Olave or Garrett Wilson? Chris Olave 54% (half-PPR)
• Ja'Marr Chase or Amon-Ra St. Brown? Ja'Marr Chase 51% (half-PPR)
• Ja'Marr Chase or Garrett Wilson? Ja'Marr Chase 54% (half-PPR)
• Ja'Marr Chase or Jordan Addison? Ja'Marr Chase 54% (half-PPR)
• Amon-Ra St. Brown or Garrett Wilson? Amon-Ra St. Brown 52% (half-PPR)
• Amon-Ra St. Brown or Jordan Addison? Amon-Ra St. Brown 54% (half-PPR)
• Amon-Ra St. Brown or Zay Flowers? Amon-Ra St. Brown 54% (half-PPR)
• Garrett Wilson or Jordan Addison? Garrett Wilson 52% (half-PPR)
• Garrett Wilson or Zay Flowers? Garrett Wilson 52% (half-PPR)
• Garrett Wilson or Puka Nacua? Garrett Wilson 53% (half-PPR)
• Jordan Addison or Zay Flowers? Jordan Addison 49% (half-PPR)
• Jordan Addison or Puka Nacua? Jordan Addison 50% (half-PPR)
• Jordan Addison or Josh Downs? Jordan Addison 52% (half-PPR)
• Zay Flowers or Puka Nacua? Zay Flowers 50% (half-PPR)
• Zay Flowers or Josh Downs? Zay Flowers 52% (half-PPR)
• Zay Flowers or CeeDee Lamb? Zay Flowers 52% (half-PPR)
• Puka Nacua or Josh Downs? Puka Nacua 51% (half-PPR)
• Puka Nacua or CeeDee Lamb? Puka Nacua 52% (half-PPR)
• Puka Nacua or Dontayvion Wicks? Puka Nacua 52% (half-PPR)
• Josh Downs or CeeDee Lamb? Josh Downs 50% (half-PPR)
• Josh Downs or Dontayvion Wicks? Josh Downs 51% (half-PPR)
• Josh Downs or Malik Washington? Josh Downs 53% (half-PPR)
• CeeDee Lamb or Dontayvion Wicks? CeeDee Lamb 51% (half-PPR)
• CeeDee Lamb or Malik Washington? CeeDee Lamb 53% (half-PPR)
• CeeDee Lamb or Nico Collins? CeeDee Lamb 53% (half-PPR)
• Dontayvion Wicks or Malik Washington? Dontayvion Wicks 52% (half-PPR)
• Dontayvion Wicks or Nico Collins? Dontayvion Wicks 52% (half-PPR)
• Dontayvion Wicks or Christian Watson? Dontayvion Wicks 52% (half-PPR)
• Malik Washington or Nico Collins? Malik Washington 50% (half-PPR)
• Malik Washington or Christian Watson? Malik Washington 51% (half-PPR)
• Malik Washington or Drake London? Malik Washington 52% (half-PPR)
• Nico Collins or Christian Watson? Nico Collins 51% (half-PPR)
• Nico Collins or Drake London? Nico Collins 51% (half-PPR)
• Nico Collins or Tetairoa McMillan? Nico Collins 52% (half-PPR)
• Christian Watson or Drake London? Christian Watson 52% (half-PPR)
• Christian Watson or Tetairoa McMillan? Christian Watson 52% (half-PPR)
• Christian Watson or Rashee Rice? Christian Watson 53% (half-PPR)
• Drake London or Tetairoa McMillan? Drake London 50% (half-PPR)
• Drake London or Rashee Rice? Drake London 51% (half-PPR)
• Drake London or Kalif Raymond? Drake London 53% (half-PPR)
• Tetairoa McMillan or Rashee Rice? Tetairoa McMillan 51% (half-PPR)
• Tetairoa McMillan or Kalif Raymond? Tetairoa McMillan 52% (half-PPR)
• Rashee Rice or Kalif Raymond? Rashee Rice 51% (half-PPR)
• Kalif Raymond or Stefon Diggs? Kalif Raymond 52% (half-PPR)
• Stefon Diggs or Mike Evans? Stefon Diggs 51% (half-PPR)
• Mike Evans or Malik Nabers? Mike Evans 51% (half-PPR)
• Mike Evans or Parker Washington? Mike Evans 51% (half-PPR)
• Malik Nabers or Parker Washington? Malik Nabers 50% (half-PPR)
• Malik Nabers or Emeka Egbuka? Malik Nabers 54% (half-PPR)
• Parker Washington or Emeka Egbuka? Parker Washington 54% (half-PPR)
• DJ Moore or DK Metcalf? DJ Moore 50% (half-PPR)
• DJ Moore or Mack Hollins? DJ Moore 52% (half-PPR)
• DK Metcalf or Mack Hollins? DK Metcalf 52% (half-PPR)

TE

• Trey McBride or Oronde Gadsden II? Trey McBride 53% (half-PPR)
• Trey McBride or Juwan Johnson? Trey McBride 58% (half-PPR)
• Trey McBride or Brock Bowers? Trey McBride 58% (half-PPR)
• Oronde Gadsden II or Juwan Johnson? Oronde Gadsden II 56% (half-PPR)
• Oronde Gadsden II or Brock Bowers? Oronde Gadsden II 55% (half-PPR)
• Oronde Gadsden II or Sam LaPorta? Oronde Gadsden II 61% (half-PPR)
• Juwan Johnson or Brock Bowers? Juwan Johnson 49% (half-PPR)
• Juwan Johnson or Sam LaPorta? Juwan Johnson 55% (half-PPR)
• Juwan Johnson or Tyler Warren? Juwan Johnson 55% (half-PPR)
• Brock Bowers or Sam LaPorta? Brock Bowers 56% (half-PPR)
• Brock Bowers or Tyler Warren? Brock Bowers 57% (half-PPR)
• Brock Bowers or Travis Kelce? Brock Bowers 57% (half-PPR)
• Sam LaPorta or Tyler Warren? Sam LaPorta 51% (half-PPR)
• Sam LaPorta or Travis Kelce? Sam LaPorta 51% (half-PPR)
• Sam LaPorta or Dalton Kincaid? Sam LaPorta 52% (half-PPR)
• Tyler Warren or Travis Kelce? Tyler Warren 51% (half-PPR)
• Tyler Warren or Dalton Kincaid? Tyler Warren 51% (half-PPR)
• Tyler Warren or Zach Ertz? Tyler Warren 54% (half-PPR)
• Travis Kelce or Dalton Kincaid? Travis Kelce 51% (half-PPR)
• Travis Kelce or Zach Ertz? Travis Kelce 53% (half-PPR)
• Travis Kelce or George Kittle? Travis Kelce 53% (half-PPR)
• Dalton Kincaid or Zach Ertz? Dalton Kincaid 52% (half-PPR)
• Dalton Kincaid or George Kittle? Dalton Kincaid 53% (half-PPR)
• Dalton Kincaid or Harold Fannin Jr.? Dalton Kincaid 53% (half-PPR)
• Zach Ertz or George Kittle? Zach Ertz 51% (half-PPR)
• Zach Ertz or Harold Fannin Jr.? Zach Ertz 51% (half-PPR)
• Zach Ertz or T.J. Hockenson? Zach Ertz 51% (half-PPR)
• George Kittle or Harold Fannin Jr.? George Kittle 50% (half-PPR)
• George Kittle or T.J. Hockenson? George Kittle 51% (half-PPR)
• George Kittle or Hunter Henry? George Kittle 53% (half-PPR)
• Harold Fannin Jr. or T.J. Hockenson? Harold Fannin Jr. 51% (half-PPR)
• Harold Fannin Jr. or Hunter Henry? Harold Fannin Jr. 54% (half-PPR)
• Harold Fannin Jr. or Dalton Schultz? Harold Fannin Jr. 53% (half-PPR)
• T.J. Hockenson or Hunter Henry? T.J. Hockenson 52% (half-PPR)
• T.J. Hockenson or Dalton Schultz? T.J. Hockenson 53% (half-PPR)
• T.J. Hockenson or Cade Otton? T.J. Hockenson 53% (half-PPR)
• Hunter Henry or Dalton Schultz? Hunter Henry 51% (half-PPR)
• Hunter Henry or Cade Otton? Hunter Henry 51% (half-PPR)
• Hunter Henry or Kenyon Sadiq? Hunter Henry 52% (half-PPR)
• Dalton Schultz or Cade Otton? Dalton Schultz 51% (half-PPR)
• Dalton Schultz or Kenyon Sadiq? Dalton Schultz 51% (half-PPR)
• Cade Otton or Kenyon Sadiq? Cade Otton 50% (half-PPR)

For entertainment and informational purposes only. 21+.